AI ROI And Maturity Scorecard
Use one row per workflow, not per tool.
The six levels below are an AI Expert OÜ house rubric, not an externally validated maturity standard. Adapt the levels to the organisation and document why each one matters.
Workflow Baseline
| Metric | Before | Pilot | After scale |
|---|---|---|---|
| Volume per week | |||
| Total labour minutes per item, including review/rework | |||
| Error/rework rate | |||
| Review minutes (subset of total, not an additional charge) | |||
| Cycle time | |||
| Customer/user satisfaction | |||
| Tool/API cost | |||
| Total labour cost, including review/rework once | |||
| Infrastructure/capacity cost | |||
| Integration, security, operations and incident cost |
Quality Metrics
| Quality check | Threshold | Result | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|
| Correct output | |||
| Source/citation correct | |||
| Format valid | |||
| Human override rate | |||
| Escalation correct |
Maturity Level
| Level | State | Current? |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | Ad hoc/no managed AI | |
| 1 | Individual productivity | |
| 2 | Repeatable workflow | |
| 3 | Governed automation | |
| 4 | Integrated system | |
| 5 | Optimized portfolio |
Scale Decision
- Scale:
- Keep small:
- Revise:
- Stop:
- Reason:
- Owner:
- Next review:
Attribution and consequence check
- Comparison design (for example holdout, phased rollout, matched baseline, or time-series):
- Other changes that could explain the result:
- Measurement window and sample:
- Negative outcomes, distributional effects, or transferred work:
- Unit value definition and finance-approved calculation:
- Evidence supporting a causal claim, or label the result as an association only:
Financial convention and synthetic check
- Period and comparable task volume/mix:
- Cash benefit versus capacity-valued benefit:
- Labour value and productive use assumption:
- Incremental versus total-cost ROI convention:
- Shared costs allocated once:
Invented check: 1,000 tasks × (7−5) minutes = 2,000 minutes = 33⅓ hours. At €30/hour, capacity value = €1,000. Incremental costs = €300 + €200 + €100 = €600; net = €400; incremental ROI ≈ 66.7%. Review/rework are already included in the seven and five minutes. This is not a measured cash saving or evidence of unchanged quality.