Markdown

AI ROI And Maturity Scorecard

Use one row per workflow, not per tool.

The six levels below are an AI Expert OÜ house rubric, not an externally validated maturity standard. Adapt the levels to the organisation and document why each one matters.

Workflow Baseline

MetricBeforePilotAfter scale
Volume per week
Total labour minutes per item, including review/rework
Error/rework rate
Review minutes (subset of total, not an additional charge)
Cycle time
Customer/user satisfaction
Tool/API cost
Total labour cost, including review/rework once
Infrastructure/capacity cost
Integration, security, operations and incident cost

Quality Metrics

Quality checkThresholdResultDecision
Correct output
Source/citation correct
Format valid
Human override rate
Escalation correct

Maturity Level

LevelStateCurrent?
0Ad hoc/no managed AI
1Individual productivity
2Repeatable workflow
3Governed automation
4Integrated system
5Optimized portfolio

Scale Decision

Attribution and consequence check

Financial convention and synthetic check

Invented check: 1,000 tasks × (7−5) minutes = 2,000 minutes = 33⅓ hours. At €30/hour, capacity value = €1,000. Incremental costs = €300 + €200 + €100 = €600; net = €400; incremental ROI ≈ 66.7%. Review/rework are already included in the seven and five minutes. This is not a measured cash saving or evidence of unchanged quality.